The habit of "self-interest" in the political-administrative structure of contemporary Iran

Document Type : .

Authors

1 . PhD student, Sociology of Social Issues, AlZahra University

2 Associate Professor of Sociology, Department of Social Sciences, AlZahra University

3 .Professor of Sociology, Department of Social Sciences, University of Tehran

Abstract

Abstract
One of the less discussed aspects of corruption in the political-administrative structure of contemporary Iran is its habitual aspect. This issue, as one of the influential factors in the development process, has been going on in a stable way in the contemporary history of Iran; For this reason, the current research, focusing on the first Pahlavi government, which is the dividing line of the appearance of modernity in the structure of the government in contemporary Iran, and based on Norbert Elias's process theory and using the historical analytical method, investigates personal gain (one of the main components of political corruption). ) in the political structure of contemporary Iran. Examining examples of this behavior in the governments of the Qajar and Pahlavi dynasties shows its prevalence (multiplicity) at all levels of power and its continuity in the investigated periods. These findings, along with paying attention to the point that this behavior has continued in the Pahlavi governments - which changed the relations and formation of the government through modernization - also prove that personal interest is a habit that goes hand in hand with the changes in the structure of the government towards modernization. did not and as a result its habitual requirements have continued to reproduce this behavior in the political-administrative structure of contemporary Iran.
 
Key words: personal interest, atawarah, habitual requirements, political structure, modernization
 
Extended abstract
It is important to deal with political corruption in various research fields, including in relation to the issue of development. One of the main components of political corruption is "personal gain" and deviation from the pattern or rule related to political power must be for the personal benefit of the holder of political power to be considered political corruption (Golmohammadi, 2012). One of the issues related to political corruption in the public and scientific environment of Iran is the politicized view that this issue (political corruption) and in fact the hidden personal gain in it by highlighting the role of individuals (politicians and government officials) ) and explains based on their individual characteristics. Acknowledging the fact that individual characteristics such as class origin and character, personality type, the person's position in the power pyramid, etc. are effective on the personal interest of individuals in the government structure, it is stated that the mere or excessive emphasis, on the role of individuals and their individual characteristics prevents the understanding of the complex process of the occurrence of this behavior in the political-administrative structure, because the importance of dealing with the structure (network of mutual dependencies) that through behavioral-emotional patterns (social habits) not only allows the occurrence It gives people this behavior, but it is less likely to lead them to this behavior. The current research aims to investigate the personal interest in the political-administrative structure of contemporary Iran (among politicians and government officials) by focusing on the first Pahlavi government, which is the dividing line of modernism in the government structure in contemporary Iran. In fact, the question in this research is: How is the existence of personal gain in the political-administrative structure whose formation has been changed by modernizing measures explained? For this purpose and in accordance with the theory of Norbert Elias that "later states arose from previous formations and configurations" (Elias, 2012: 244), first the examples of this behavior in the states of the Qajar dynasty (without considering the constitution as a stream of modernization in The structure of the late Qajar states made some changes), and then we examine the modernist states of the first and second Pahlavi. This research is based on interpretative paradigm, and it was done with case-oriented approach and historical-analytical method. In this method, research is based on a type of context, temporality and causal conditions. The most fundamental difference that the historical-analytical method has with other methods is the type of research data and the way they are used. Although many sociologists and historians doubt the necessity of narrative in historical sociology, historical sociology recommends emphasizing the connection of a historical process that may not exist to reality, and this implies that the present includes the past; That is, the past that we intend to know more about is how the present has been reconstructed (Hamilton et al., 2008: 112). Based on this, historical analysis does not mean the use of data related to the past, but the narration of the sequence of events and contextual, temporal and processual analysis of historical events. Examining the examples shows the extent and continuity of personal gain in the political structure of the examined governments. Based on the extent (multiplicity) of this behavior, we concluded that this behavior is ongoing in the political structure of contemporary Iran as a habit that carries habitual requirements, and it should be explained accordingly. Based on its continuity, especially in the Pahlavi governments, which created a transformation in the relations and formation of the government with the strategy of modernization, we concluded by citing Elias' theory that this behavior (personality structure) has not changed along with the changes that happened in the government structure. , and as a result, its habitual requirements have persisted. The importance of explaining personal gain from the habitual aspect that leads to a more accurate understanding of the complex process of the occurrence of this behavior in the political structure of contemporary Iran is important because it is a necessary step in the direction of more targeted and correct intervention to correct this behavior.

Keywords


  • Abbaszadeh Marzbali, Majid (2016). "Formation of the Rantiner government and its effect on the collapse of the second Pahlavi regime", Development Strategy Journal, No. 52, pp. 83-46. ]in Persian[
  • Abrahamian, Yerevan (2009). History of Modern Iran, translated by Mohammad Ebrahim Fatahi, Tehran: Ney Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Abrahamian, Yerevan (2013). Iran between two revolutions, translated by Ahmad Golmohammadi and Mohammad Ebrahim Fatahi, Tehran: Ney Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Afshar, Zain al-Abidin (2019). Sociological investigation of the causes of inefficiency of anti-corruption policies and programs in Iran after the revolution, commissioned by the Center for Presidential Strategic Studies, Tehran: Strategy Book. ]in Persian[
  • Alam, Amir Asadullah (1992). My conversations with the Shah, translated by the group of translators, Tehran: New Design Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Alikhani, Behrouz (2015). "Looking at the socio-psychological contexts of the failure of the constitutional government and Reza Khan's rise to power in Iran", Iranian Journal of Sociology, 16th volume, numbers 1 and 2, pp. 31-54. ]in Persian[
  • Alizadeh Birjandi, Zahra and Naseri, Akram (2019). "Retelling the cultural-social history of the Qajar period based on the folk poems of that period", Scientific Quarterly of History of Iran after Islam, year 11, number 24, pp. 145-169. ]in Persian[
  • Amanat, Abbas (2020). The history of modern Iran, the fifth part, translated by M. Hafiz, caffeine bookly.com. ]in Persian[
  • Anwari, Ibrahim; Salah Menesh, Ahmed; Sheikh Ansari, Majid; Moradi, Mahosh (2015). "Does the interaction between corruption and financial liberalization affect economic growth? Evidence from oil exporting countries", Journal of Economic Growth and Development Research, No. 24, pp. 115-128. ]in Persian[
  • Avari, Peter (1992). Contemporary history of Iran (from August 28 coup to land reforms), third volume, translated by Mohammad Rafiei Mehrabadi, Tehran: Atai Publications Institute. ]in Persian[
  • Avari, Peter (1992). Contemporary history of Iran (from the establishment of the Pahlavi dynasty to the coup d'état of August 28, 1332), volume two, translated by Mohammad Rafiei Mehrabadi, Tehran: Atai Publications Institute. ]in Persian[
  • Azimi, Fakhreddin (2021). Hoyt Iran, Tehran: Aghat Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Bazargan, Mehdi (1978). Iranian compatibility, Tehran: Houston, book distribution office. ]in Persian[
  • Blakey, Norman (2007). Designing social researches, translated by Hassan Chavoshian, Tehran: Nei Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Bourdieu, Pierre (2011). Sports actions and social actions, translated by Mohammad Reza Farzad, Organon Quarterly, No. 20, pp. 227-246. ]in Persian[
  • Burhani, Mina (2017), "Investigation of the causes of priority of individual interest over collective in two-way social situations (with special emphasis on the phenomenon of free and unauthorized use of electric energy in Kerman city)". (Master's thesis in the field of social sciences, research orientation, Mazandaran University, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences). ]in Persian[
  • Dadashi, Alireza (2011). "Fighting against administrative corruption in Iran: measures taken and some proposed solutions", Development strategy journal, number 27, pp. 208-220. ]in Persian[
  • Derakhshani, Ali Akbar (2007). The full text of Brigadier General Ali Akbar Derakhshani's memoirs, edited by Shidan Derakhshani, Harvard University Oral History Collection of Iran, Tehran: Page Sefid Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Elias, Norbert (2012). What is Sociology, translated by Gholamreza Khadevi, Tehran: Sociologists Publications.
  • Elias, Norbert (2015). On the process of civilization (studies in its sociological and psychological development), translated by Gholamreza Khadevi, Tehran: Sociologists Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Etemad al-Sultaneh, Mohammad Hassan Khan (1966). Etemad al-Sultaneh newspaper, by the efforts of Iraj Afshar, Tehran: Amirkabir publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Etemad al-Sultaneh, Mohammad Hassan Khan (1969). Khlase famous for dream book, by Mahmoud Katiraei, Tehran: Mihan printing house. ]in Persian[
  • Faraji, Mehdi (2015). Norbert Elias and the analysis of civilization, Tehran: Publisher of Culture and Communication Research Institute. ]in Persian[
  • Farastkhah, Maqsood (2014). We Iranians; Historical and social research of Iranian peoples, Tehran: Nei Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Fardoost, Hossein (1995). The Rise and Fall of the Pahlavi Dynasty, Tehran: Institute of Political Studies and Research. ]in Persian[
  • Fazli, Habib Elah and Rajabi, Hadi (2022). "The institution supporting education and the fall of Pahlavi II in the framework of the new institutionalism approach", State Research Quarterly, Year 8, Number 29, pp. 88-120. ]in Persian[
  • Foran, John (2014). Fragile resistance (the history of Iran's social transformations from Safavid to the years after the Islamic revolution), translated by Ahmad Tedin, Tehran: Rasa Cultural Services Institute. ]in Persian[
  • Freund, Julien (1989). Sociology of Max Weber, translated by Abdul Hossein Nik Gahar, Tehran: Daizen. ]in Persian[
  • Ghazi Moradi, Hassan (2008). On the self-control of Iranians (a study in the social psychology of Iran), Tehran: Akhtaran Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Golmohammadi, Ahmed (2012). "Pathology of the state in Iran during the Pahlavi period: political corruption according to documents", Journal of Political Science, 8th year, 2nd issue, pp. 49-78. ]in Persian[
  • Grafland, Yohan (2012). "Personal Interest", translated by Mohammad Taghi Jan Mohammadi, Mobeen's Equestrian Journals, first year, number 6, pp. 1-11. ]in Persian[
  • Hakimi, Mahmoud (1986). Stories from the era of Naser al-Din Shah, Tehran: Nash Qalam. ]in Persian[
  • Hamilton, Gary J., Randall Collins and others (2008). Historiography and historical sociology, translated by Hashim Aghajari, Tehran: Nash Kavir. ]in Persian[
  • Hanish, Natalie (2010). Sociology of Norbert Elias, translated by Abdul Hossein Nik Gohar, Tehran: Ney Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Haseibi, Rabab (1992). "Famine and price in the lunar year 1287 and 1288", Ganjineh Sanad Magazine, No. 7 and 8, pp. 63-47. ]in Persian[
  • Hughes, Stuart (1990). Consciousness and society, translated by Ezatollah Foulavand, Tehran: Islamic Revolution Education. ]in Persian[
  • Ivanov, Vladimir Alexey Vych (2012). Farsi in Birjand dialect, translated by Mahmoud Rafiei, Tehran: Hirmand. ]in Persian[
  • Jamali Asgoi, Seyyed Jamal; Bakshaishi Ardestani, Ahmed; Bani Hashemi, Mir Qasim (2019). "Political Economy of Corruption in the Islamic Republic of Iran", Majles and Strategy Quarterly, Year 27, Number 111, pp. 33-58. ]in Persian[
  • Jamalzadeh, Mohammad Ali (1966). People of our Iranians, Tehran: Foroughi Bookstore. ]in Persian[
  • Katouzian, Mohammad Ali Homayun (1993). Iran's political economy (from constitutionalism to the end of the Pahlavi dynasty), translated by Mohammad Reza Nafisi and Kambyz Azizi, Tehran: Nahr-e-Karzan. ]in Persian[
  • Katouzian, Mohammad Ali Homayun (2000). Sultan regimes: the case of the Pahlavi regime in Iran", translators Amir Mohammad Haji Yousefi and Mohammad Saeed Qaeni Najafi, Journal of Political-Economic Information, numbers 153 and 154. ]in Persian[
  • Katouzian, Mohammad Ali Homayun (2008). The conflict between the state and the nation (the theory of history and politics in Iran), translated by Alireza Tayeb, Tehran: Nei Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Khedevi, Gholamreza (2012). "Agency and structure from the perspective of process sociology of Norbert Elias", Iranian Journal of Sociological Studies, Volume 2, Number 6, Pages 151-135. ]in Persian[
  • Lajordi, Habib (1985-1986). Iran Oral History Project, Volume I, Harvard University. ]in Persian[
  • Mahalati, Mohammad Ali (1967). Memoirs of Haj Sayah, by Hamid Sayah, Tehran: Ibn Sina Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Majduddin, Akbar (2004). "Norbert Elias, the founder of process sociology", Cognition Journal, numbers 41 and 42, pages 131-148. ]in Persian[
  • Makki, Hossein (1995). "Twenty Year History", Volume 6, Tehran: Scientific Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Maragheh, Zain al-Abidin (2005), Ebrahim Bey's travel book, vol. 1, Tehran: Aghaz. ]in Persian[
  • Marbat, Yahya; Keshafinia, Vahid; Abbasi, Mustafa; Wathghi, Mohammad; Fallahian, Mehdi (2019). Conflict of interest in the public sector, Tehran: Transparency and progress publication. ]in Persian[
  • Mohit Tabatabai, Mohammad (1984). Collection of works of Mirza Malkam Khan, Tehran: Scientific Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Moidfar, Saeed; Ahmadi, Hossein (2010). "Political corruption and political stability", Iranian Sociology Journal, 11th volume, number 4, pages 56-81. ]in Persian[
  • Mostofi, Abdullah (1983). Narration of my life (social and administrative history of the Qajar period), third volume, Tehran: Zovar Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Najmabadi, Efsane (1995). The story of the girls of Qochan (forgotten stories of the constitutional revolution), Sweden: Baran Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Naraghi, Hassan (2001). Casual sociology; Why are we helpless, Tehran: Akhtaran. ]in Persian[
  • Natiq, Homa (1978). It is from us that it comes, Tehran: Aghat Publications. ]in Persian[
  • Qadri, Tahira, and Al-Qouna, Zahra (2016), "Investigation of selfish individualism and its related factors among students of Shiraz University". Social Sciences Quarterly, year 26, number 79, pp. 1-31. ]in Persian[
  • Rain, Ismail (1994). British wage earners in Iran, 9th edition, Tehran: Scientific Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Rajabzadeh, Hashem (1997) "Description of the Iranians in the travelogues of the Japanese", Farhangistan Journal, No. 9, pp. 171-162. ]in Persian[
  • Rezaqoli, Ali (1998). Sociology of elitism; Qaim Maqam, Amir Kabir and Mossadegh: Sociological analysis of some historical roots of tyranny and backwardness in Iran, 6th edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Rigin, Charles (2008). The comparative method beyond quantitative and qualitative strategy, translated by Mohammad Fazli, Tehran: Aghaz Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Russell, Bertrand (2008). The world I know, translated by Ruhollah Abbasi, Tehran: Amirkabir publishing. ]in Persian[
  • Saei, Ali (2013) "Logic of historical comparative analysis with Boolean analysis approach", Journal of Social Sciences (Allameh Tabatabai University), No. 54, pp. 127-164. ]in Persian[
  • Sai, Ali (2016). Research method in social sciences (with the approach of critical rationality), Tehran: Samit Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Salmani, Fatemeh (2019), "Investigating the causes of preference of individual over collective benefits among Tehrani citizens". (Master's thesis in social science research field, Khwarazmi University, Faculty of Literature and Humanities). ]in Persian[
  • Samii Esfahani, Alireza; Shafii Seifabadi, Mohsen; Yaqub Nia, Hassan (2017). "Political culture and its influence on the behavior of elites and political development in the second Pahlavi period", Iranian Political Sociology Quarterly, first year, first issue, pp. 105-129. ]in Persian[
  • Saree al-Qalam, Mahmoud (2006). Political Culture of Iran, Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies. ]in Persian[
  • Sayah, Mohammad Ali (1967). Memoirs of Haj Sayah or the Period of Fear and Fear, by Hamid Sayah and corrected by Saifullah Golkar, Tehran: Amir Kabir Publishing House. ]in Persian[
  • Scotchpool, Teda (2008). Insight and Method in Historical Sociology, translated by Hashem Aghajari, Tehran: Center. ]in Persian[
  • Shamsi, Farhad (2017), "Investigating the social contexts of the tendency towards individual self-interest among the citizens of Tabriz in 2017". (Master's thesis in sociology, Tabriz University, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences). ]in Persian[
  • Yazidi, Ali Mohammad (2002). Why are we lagging behind? Sociology of Iranian people, Tehran: Alam Publishing. ]in Persian[