Sociological View to the Concept of Environmental Regulation in the Light of Principles 8 and 50 of the Constitution of Iran

Document Type : .

Authors

1 Assossiate Professor, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran.

2 PhD student of Public Law, Tehran University, Kish Campus, Kish. Iran

Abstract

Since the environment is the biological foundation of humans and other living beings, it is of fundamental and undeniable importance; But despite this position, global industrial and technological development, especially in the last two centuries, has caused unwanted and often unpleasant changes and environmental destruction in many parts of the world. Therefore, many governments are forced to regulate directly and indirectly in the field of environmental protection and improvement. In Iran, by applying legal regulations, the government is trying to solve environmental problems and challenges and at least prevent its destruction and erosion as a social problem; As Article 50 of the Iranian Constitution also emphasizes on environmental regulation. Using the descriptive and analytical method and with a sociological point of view, the following article examines the way of environmental regulation in the light of Article 8 and 50 of the Constitution. The findings of the current research show that by taking advantage of the capacities of the existing law, a combined approach should be adopted that takes advantage of the benefits and efficiency of other regulatory methods to compensate for the shortcomings and fill the gaps of a single approach.
Keyword: Sociology, Regulation, Environment, Principle8, Principle 50
Introduction
In its current state, the environment is facing serious threats such as climate change, weather pollution, species extinction, biodiversity loss, and irresponsible exploitation of irreversible natural resources. The consequences of these threats will not only affect the lives of humans and other living beings today, but will continue for generations to come, and the consequences of any decision to deal with it will be felt for a long time; Therefore, as a result of the unbreakable and tight connection of the environment with a set of factors and conditions on which the life and durability of living beings depend, there is an urgent need for a precise definition of environmental rights and a set of rules and regulations that regulate the relationship between humans and the environment. and monitor it. Such rules help preserve the environment and natural resources, prevent their further damage and destruction, and maintain the balance between humans and the environment.
Materials & Methods
Using the descriptive and analytical method and with a sociological point of view, the following article examines the way of environmental regulation in the light of Article 8 and 50 of the Constitution.
Discussion
Although there are various definitions of regulation, these definitions can be categorized into three levels: centralized, middle, and decentralized. At the first level, the conventional definition of regulation is as a tool for "command and control" implemented by bureaucratic institutions. At the second or middle level, regulation consists of standards, rules, and after that, monitoring and feedback mechanisms and finally the implementation of these rules. At the third level, there is a decentralized regulatory approach or a community-oriented approach; According to this approach, regulation refers to the process of creating and implementing rules and behavioral standards that promote the welfare and safety of society as a whole. In general, regulation can be defined as follows; Regulation means the application of rules and regulations based on certain criteria and its purpose is to influence and regulate behavior, the flow of affairs or events. This activity can be done by the public and private sectors with the participation of stakeholders in the economic and social fields in order to provide benefits, good and public welfare. The purpose of this activity is to ensure optimal production, distribution of goods and services, and social support. The implementation of regulation and its supervision is the responsibility of the regulator or interested participants. There are several approaches to legal regulation in the field of environment and different countries may adopt different approaches based on their legal traditions, political and social values and economic conditions. In general, the main regulatory approaches in the field of environment can be considered as command and control-based regulatory approach, market-oriented regulation, voluntary regulation and cooperative regulation.
Result
In the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, in addition to Article 50, Article 8 can also be considered. The eighth principle of the constitution considers calling for good, enjoining what is good and forbidding what is bad to be everyone's duty, and it is the responsibility of the people and the government to do it. If we consider environmental protection as an example of good and well-known, we will notice the issuance of implicit permission of the constitution in the use of a hybrid approach of regulation in the field of environment. Article 4 of the Executive Regulations on the Establishment and Activities of Non-Governmental Organizations and Note 2 of Article 16 of the Law on Amendments to the Law on Organizations and Procedures of the Court of Administrative Justice has created the capacity for environmental protection organizations to investigate feedback on the activities of government agencies in this area, obtain information and even file a lawsuit. do These organizations have the right to comment and provide solutions in this regard while examining the existing defects and problems. Government agencies are also allowed to provide non-classified information to non-governmental organizations. The totality of this legal capacity regarding the involvement of non-governmental organizations in the environment and the ineffectiveness of the laws approved as the basis of the principles of the constitution makes it clearer the need to use other approaches and even the use of a multiple approach in the sense of using all regulatory methods in protecting the environment.

Keywords


 
Abdulahi, M., Sajdi, Z., Faradi, M., Ramezani Ghavamabadi, M. (2013). Environmental Criminal Law: Considerations and Solutions, Tehran: Official Newspaper of Iran. [in Persian].
Alidadi Shams Abadi, M., Nasiri, A., & Safi, S. (2019). “ Comparison of the right to a healthy environment in the conduct of Prophet and the Infallible with constitutional rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran”. Journal of History and Culture, 51(2), 264-245. [in Persian].
Berck, P. (2018). The Theory and Practice of Command and Control in Environmental Policy. United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis.
Carol J. Pierce Colfer, Ravi Prabhu(2023). Responding to Environmental Issues through Adaptive Collaborative Management: From Forest Communities to Global Actors. Routledge/Earthscan.
Coglianese, Cary and Nash, Jennifer, (2016). "Motivating Without Mandates: The Role of Voluntary Programs in Environmental Governance". Faculty Scholarship at Penn Carey Law. 1647.
Cultural Institute of Fiqh al-Saqlain (2015). Enjoining the Good and Forbidding the Evil: Taken From the Jurisprudential Views of the Supreme authority of Hazrat Ayatollah Azami Sanei Mudzala al-Ali, Qom: Fiqh al-Saqlain. [in Persian].
Driesen, David M.(2018). “EMISSIONS TRADING VERSUS POLLUTION TAXES: PLAYING ‘NICE’ WITH OTHER INSTRUMENTS.” Environmental Law, vol. 48, no. 1, pp. 29–80.
Foreman, jo, (2018). Developments in environmental regulation. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ghavam, M. (2012). Criminal Protection of the Environment, Tehran: Publications of the Environmental Protection Organization. [in Persian].
Gieseke, Timothy. (2019). Collaborative Environmental Governance Frameworks: A Practical Guide. CRC Press
Greenwood, Steven; Singer, Laurel; Willis, Wendy(2021). Collaborative Governance: Principles, Processes, and Practical Tools. Routledge.
Guo, Xu & Fu, Lin & Sun, Xiaohua. (2021). Can Environmental Regulations Promote Greenhouse Gas Abatement in OECD Countries? Command-and-Control vs. Market-Based Policies. Sustainability. 13. 6913.
Hadavand, M., jam, F. (2021). The Concept of Regulatory State: An Analysis of Regulation as Instrument of Governance. Strategy, 30(2), 227-266. [in Persian].
Hartlapp, Miriam. (2020). Measuring and Comparing the Regulatory Welfare State: Social Objectives in Public Procurement. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 691.
Heyvaert, Veerle. (2018). Transnational Environmental Regulation and Governance: Purpose, Strategies and Principles. Cambridge University Press
katoozian, N. (2004). Transition to editing Draft Constitution. Basic Rights, 1(1), 115-138. [in Persian].
Katoozian., N,.  Ansari., M. (2008). Liability for Environmental Damage. Law Quarterly, 38(2). [in Persian].
Levi-Faur, David(2014). The welfare state: a regulatory perspective. Public Administration 92 (3): 599–
Levi-Faur, David. (2011). The Odyssey of the Regulatory State: Episode One: The Rescue of the Welfare State. Jerusalem Papers in Regulation & Governance, 1(39), 1-35.
Presidential Strategic Studies Center (2020). " An introduction on regulatory government", Tehran: Presidential Strategic Research Center. [in Persian].
Prosser, Tony(2010). The Regulatory Enterprise: Government, Regulation, and Legitimacy. OUP Oxford
Ramezani Ghavamabadi, M. H. (2013). The preservation of the environment in Iran's constitution. The Quarterly Journal of Judicial Law Views, 18(63), 93-140. [in Persian].
Schmitz, B. (2022). Rethinking the Public Interest in Consumer Protection, European Journal of Comparative Law and Governance, 9(2), 210-235.
Shahdadenjad, N,. Jafari, A., Jalalian, A. (2019). "Responsibility of the coastal state in environmental pollution with emphasis on the principle of participation in the Convention on the Law of the Sea", Research of the Nations, No. 61, 67-90. [in Persian].
Shilton, D., Kiss, A (2014). Judicial Book of Environmental Rights, researched and translated by Mohsen Abdulahi, Tehran: Khorsandi Publications. [in Persian].
Singhal, Puja )2018(. ."Environmental Regulations: Lessons from the Command-and-Control Approach," DIW Roundup: Politik im Fokus 124, DIW Berlin, German Institute for Economic Research.
Vatan Dost, p., Javaheri Babli., Mehran. (1383). Survey of environmental crimes in Iran, Ahvaz: Islamic Azad University. [in Persian].
Windholz, Eric, & Hodge, Graeme A. (2012). Conceptualising Social and Economic Regulation: Implications for Modern Regulators and Regulatory Activity. Monash University Law Review, 38(49), 212-237.
Documents:
 The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran 1989
Executive regulations for the establishment and activities of non-governmental organizations 2014
Law of the First Program of Economic, Social and Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran (approved on 31/1/1990)
Law of the Second Economic, Social and Cultural Development Program of the Islamic Republic of Iran (approved on 11/12/1994)
The Law of the Third Program of Economic, Social and Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran (approved on 11/06/2013)
Environmental protection and improvement law approved 18/6/1974
Hunting and fishing law, approved in 1967
Islamic Penal Code approved 1996
Civil Law of Iran 1928
Vision document of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the horizon of 2025
General policies of the system (promulgated by the Supreme Leader)