Measuring the relationship between social capital components and political trust among West Azerbaijan citizens

Document Type : .

Authors

1 Ph.D. in Political Science with a focus on Iranian Affairs, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

3 Associate Professor of Political Science, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran

10.30465/scs.2024.9220

Abstract

The purpose of the present study was to measure the relationship between the social capital components and political trust of West Azerbaijan citizens through a survey method among all citizens over the age of 18 in West Azerbaijan province (2,284,359 cases). The sample size was determined to be 384 through the random sampling method using a questionnaire. The findings of Cronbach's alpha validity coefficient showed that all items of the variables had the necessary and desirable reliability. The results of Pearson's coefficient test indicated a significant correlation between all variables. Based on the multiple regression test, political trust in West Azerbaijan province depends on an increase in political participation (16%), an increase in forgiveness and volunteer spirit (18%), an increase in religious participation (15%), and an increase in justice in civil participation (35%). Therefore, increasing the level of social capital among the citizens will enhance their political trust resulting in the expansion of people’s civil and social participation.
Keywords: Social capital, political participation, civil partnership, political trust, West Azerbaijan province.

Introduction and statement of the problem

The most important symbol of political participation is the conscious participation of citizens in elections, and the more these participations are. The level of political and social legitimacy of the system increases. Therefore, it can be claimed that the highest form of crystallization of democracy in society is through their participation in elections. The results related to the participation of the people of West Azerbaijan Province in the elections between the ninth, tenth and eleventh periods of the Islamic Council show a significant decrease. One of the important components of increasing political participation is paying attention to public trust and social capital. When the level of public trust is high, civic participation also increases. Also, the greater the participation in the elections, the greater the political stability. It seems that the issue of social capital has a special effect on the level of political trust of the citizens of West Azerbaijan and affects their level of civic participation. At the end of this question, what is the relationship between the social capital components of West Azerbaijan citizens and their political trust? According to the research question, the following goals have been considered: - Identifying the relationship between the components of social capital and political trust.

Research methodology

This article was conducted with a survey method among 2,284,359 citizens over 18 years of age in West Azarbaijan province as a statistical population, and using Cochran's formula, 384 people were selected as the sample size. The tool of data collection was the technique of documentary studies and written interview (questionnaire). 11 items to measure political trust (as a dependent variable). To measure independent research variables including: 1. social trust variable, 7 items; 2. Political participation variable, number of 6 items; 3. Participation and civic leadership variable, 6 items; 4. Informal social relations variable, 7 items; 5. The variable of forgiveness and the spirit of volunteering, the number of 6 items; 6. Religious participation variable, number of 6 items; 7. The variable of justice in civil participation, number of 6 items; 8. The variable of socializing and friendship diversity was designed using 6 items and measured and evaluated using a five-point Likert scale. SPSS software was used to analyze the collected data.

Research findings
According to the output of the descriptive statistics of the research data for 384 respondents, it can be said: the highest distribution of contextual variables related to gender is related to the "male" option (%53.9). The lowest distribution corresponds to the "female" option (%46.1). The highest distribution of contextual variables related to education is related to the "Bachelor's" option (%26.3) and the lowest distribution is related to the " Subdiploma " option (%9.9).
Reliability analysis of the items related to the main research variables in this research, based on Cronbach's alpha reliability coefficient which is more than 70%, it can be said that all the items related to each of the main research variables have the necessary and desirable reliability in using the items, The target in the research questionnaire has. Has J. Inferential statistics (hypotheses) of the research variables, the results of the Pearson correlation coefficient test showed: Considering the significance level obtained for all the independent research variables, which is equal to (0.000), it can be concluded that all the components related to the independent variable have an effect on political trust and all the independent variables have a significant relationship with the dependent variable. Therefore, the hypotheses are accepted. The research hypothesis can be tested using multiple regression analysis. Collinearity test was used to measure the goodness of the regression model of the effective factors (V/X) on the dependent variable (Y). The multivariable hypothesis (for the purpose of multiple regression analysis) is as follows: It seems that political trust (dependent variable) in West Azerbaijan province can depend on (main research variables): 1. Social trust. 2. Political participation; 3. Civil partnership; 4. Informal social links; 5. Forgiveness and the spirit of volunteering; 6. Religious participation; 7. Justice in civil participation and 8. Diversity of associations and friendships. According to the results of the multivariable hypothesis test, the research model is drawn as follows: Figure 1: Experimental research model (within the framework of the multivariable research hypothesis).

(within the framework of the multivariate research hypothesis).




 (β=.158)
Political Participation








Political Trust








(β=.181)
Forgiveness and the spirit of volunteering








(β=.148)
Religious Participation








(β=.349)
Justice in Civil Partnership





Discussion and conclusion

In this article, citing the statistical findings and based on the explanatory theories of the main research variables, i.e. the theory of Putnam, Coleman, Bordo, Fukuyama and other thinkers It was observed that the results of this article are consistent with the opinions of the mentioned researchers. Therefore, it can be said that with the increase of social capital among the citizens of West Azarbaijan province, the level of their political trust will also increase and, in parallel, the level of civic and social participation will also increase. According to the findings and results of the research, the following suggestions are presented: - Investigate the issue of social trust and its role in increasing political trust. -Investigating the issue of informal social links that play a vital and constructive role in increasing the political trust of citizens. -Considering that one of the important results of political trust is the high civil and social participation of citizens, this matter has been given serious attention and studies should be done regarding the increase of this participation. -The greater the political and social trust of the citizens, the more forgiveness and voluntary spirit they will have. Therefore, it is suggested to measure the component of forgiveness and the spirit of volunteering and suggest ways to improve it. -There is a significant relationship between religious participation and the level of political trust, and therefore, in-depth investigations are necessary to investigate the roots of this increase in participation.

Keywords


Afshani, Seyed Alireza and Shiri, Hamida (2018). Social capital from theory to measurement. Tehran: Andisheh Ehsan. [In Persian]
Akbaritbar, Aliakbar (2016). "Factors and virtual social capital of Iranians". Doctoral dissertation in the field of social welfare. Tutor Jafar Hazarjaribi. Consultant professors Ali Sai and Mohammad Saeed Zakai. Tehran: Allameh Tabatabai University. [In Persian]
Asghari, Harmat and Asadi, Ismail (2012). "The effect of accountability on public trust and political trust (case study: Iran's government organizations)". State Management Mission Quarterly. 4 (9-10). 53-75. [In Persian]
Azizian, Omid (2015). "The role of social capital in promoting political development (a case study of Kurdistan province of Iran after the Islamic revolution of 1357)". Master thesis of social sciences. Supervisor Masao Akhwankazemi. Consultant Professor Bahram Nasrallahizadeh. Kermanshah: Razi University. [In Persian]
Bagheri, Masoumeh; Hosseinzadeh, Alihossein and Shujaei, Hassan (2017). "Investigation of the impact of social capital dimensions (social trust, feeling of powerlessness, social harmony, and Social connection) on women's political participation in Khuzestan province (case study: Ahvaz city)". Social Development Quarterly (formerly Human Development). 12 (3). 62-29. [In Persian]
Bain, K. & Hicks, N. (1998). "Building social capital and reaching out to excluded groups: The challenge of partnerships". In Paper presented at CELAM meeting on The Struggle against Poverty towards the Turn of the Millennium. Washington D.C.
Bourdieu, P. & Acquaint, I. (2020). An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bretzer, N. (2002). "How Can Institution Better Explain Political Trust Than Capital Do?" PHD Theses. Sweden: University of Gothenburg.
Christian Reseatch Association (2014). Social Capital and Religion in Contemporary Australia. Australia: Christian Research Association.
Coleman, Robert (2017). Foundations of social theory. Translated by Manouchehr Sabouri. Tehran: Ney Publishing.
Fahandjasadi, Seyyedh Masouma (1401). "The effect of religiosity on political trust in the Islamic Republic of Iran". Research paper on the history of politics and media. 2 (18). 105-128. [In Persian]
Farjiainanlu, Mojtabi (2015). "Investigating the impact of social capital on the development of political participation (a case study of people aged 18-65 in Qazvin city)". Master's thesis in the field of political science. Supervisor Mohammad Rahim Ayouzi. Consultant professor Gurban Ali Gurbanzadeh. Tehran: Imam Khomeini International University. [In Persian]
Fokuyama, F (2015), Trust: The Social Virtuous and the Creation of Prosperity; New York; The Free Press.
Fukuyama, Francis (1400). End of order Translated by Gholam Abbas Tavasli. Tehran: Sociologists Publications. [In Persian]
Gabriel, O.W. (2015). Political efficacy and trust. Oxford university press.
Gamson, W. (2010). Power and discontent. Homewood: Dorsey Press.
Ghafarinvin, Shirin (2015). "Investigation of political trust and factors affecting it". Master's thesis in the field of social science research. Supervisor Mohammad Amin Ghaneirad and advisor Mansoureh Azam Azadeh. Tehran: Al-Zahra University. [In Persian]
Hajizadeh, Hamdollah (2017). "Examination of the relationship between social capital and attitude towards democracy (case study of Tehran University students)". Master's thesis in sociology. Supervisor Abulfazl Zulfaqari. Tehran: Shahid University. [In Persian]
Hetherington, M.J. (1998). "The Political Relevance of Political Trust". American Political Science Review. 92 (4). 791- 808.
Huntington, Samuel (1400). Political order in societies undergoing transformation. Translated by Mohsen Teri. Tehran: Science. [In Persian]
Jahangiri, Jahangir and Abutrabizarchi, Fatemeh (2011). "Analysis of factors related to students' political trust (survey among students of Shiraz University)". Biannual scientific-research journal of political knowledge. Year 8 (2). 5-26. [In Persian]
Khanbashi, Mohammad (1390A). "A model for measuring environmental strategic factors affecting public trust (a systematic framework for analyzing factors affecting political trust)". Doctoral dissertation in public administration, majoring in human resource management. Supervisor Shamsalsadat Zahedi. Mahdi Elwani and Vejhollah Ghorbanizadeh consultant professor. Tehran: Allameh Tabatabai University. [In Persian]
Khanbashi, Mohammad (2013). "Effect of economic factors on the level of political trust". Strategy Quarterly. Twentieth year 61. 277-315. [In Persian]
Khoshfar, Gholamreza and others (2018). "Investigating the relationship between social capital and political participation of citizens (case study: Gorgan city)". Contemporary sociology researches. 8 (14). 27-52. [In Persian]
Kianinjad, Amin (2012). "Effective factors on citizens' social trust in political socialization institutions". Master's thesis. Supervisor Mohammad Reza Taliban. Tehran: Imam Khomeini Research Institute (Rh). [In Persian]
Krishna, A. & Shrader, E. (2020). Social Capital and Poverty Reduction. The World Bank.
Larson, L. (2007). "Public Trust in the PR Industry and its Actors". Journal of Communication Management. 11 (3). 222- 234.
Ministry of Interior (1400). "Investigation of the participation status of the citizens of West Azarbaijan Province in the elections of the Islamic Council from 2010 to 2019". Tehran: Ministry of Interior.
Mirfardi, A. (2022). "The Role of Political and Media Factors in Trust in Political Fractions in Shiraz city". Research Letter of Political Science. 17 (3). 195-225.
Moradi, Salar (2016). "Effective factors on political trust in Iran after the Islamic Revolution (case study: Kurdistan province)". Doctoral dissertation in the field of political science, Iranian issues. Supervisor Abolfazl Delavari. Heshmatullah Falahatpisheh and Mustafa Kavakbian, advisor professor. Tehran: Allameh Tabatabai University. [In Persian]
Najafpour, Sara and Tadinrad, Ali (1400). "The relationship between social mobility and education level with political trust (case study of Ahvaz citizens). Biannual scientific journal of political knowledge. 18 (1). 279-306. [In Persian]
Newton, K. (2011). "Trust, Social Capital, Civil Society and Democracy". International Political Science Review. 22 (2). 121- 128.
Ports, A. (1998). "Social Capital: Its Original and Applications in Modern Sociology". Annual Review of Sociology. 1. 1- 24.
Putnam, Robert (1400). Democracy and Civic Traditions (Social Capital and Civic Traditions in Modern Italy). Translated by Mohammad Taghi Delfrooz. Tehran: Sociologists Publications. [In Persian]
Redadi, Mohsen, (1400). The theory of political trust with emphasis on Islamic discourse. Tehran: Imam Sadegh University. [In Persian]
Rouhani, Mohsen and others (1401). "The role of radio and television in strengthening political trust". Scientific Quarterly Journal of Mass Communication Media. 33 (2). 5-28. [In Persian]
Royaei, Ramzan Ali and Kaousi, Ismail (2007). "Designing and developing a social capital measurement model". Future research of management. 76. 15-29. [In Persian]
Sabine, T, Koeszegi, T. (2004). "Trust- Building Strategies in Inter-Organizational Negotiations". Journal of Managerial Psychology. 19 (6). 640- 660.
Sardarnia, Khalilala; Gudari, Hossein and Islam, Alireza (2018). "The effect of good governance and social capital on political trust: a case study; the cities of Mashhad and Sabzevar". Political science research paper. 5 (1). 135-165. [In Persian]
Sharapour, Mahmoud (1387). "Global trends in measuring social capital: effectiveness from the field of socialization policy". Management and development process. 68 and 69. 29-5. [In Persian]
Uslaner, E. (2022). The moral foundations of trust. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Zahedi, Shams al-Sadat and Khanbashi, Mohammad (2010). "From public trust to political trust". Management research in Iran. 15 (4). 73-97. [In Persian]