The lifestyle of Lorestan's women from the point of view of tourists, military and political advisors

Document Type : .

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate of architecture, Department of Architecture, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University. Isfahan, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Technical and Vocational University, Tehran, Iran.

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University. Isfahan, Iran

4 Associate professor, Department of Architecture, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University. Isfahan, Iran.

10.30465/scs.2023.9130

Abstract

Knowing the way of life of women can be effective in understanding their family and social status in any historical period. The general perception of the status of women in the traditional lifestyle of Iranian people is the subordinate and inferior role of women. Readings based on lifestyle in social science have provided an opportunity to review these presuppositions arising from the literature of the early modern period; Therefore, in the upcoming qualitative research, using the historical ethnographic method and relying on documentary sources and data analysis in a descriptive-analytical way, the way of life of Lorestan women in the Qajar period is tried to be represented based on the travelogues of travelers, military and political advisors. Questions such as how was Lorestan's women's lifestyle based on tourists' information.The result of the current research question the frequent beliefs of the superior position of men and the inferiority of women in the region. and reflects the reciprocal relationship between men's and women's lifestyles in the region at the two levels of society and family. It led to the sociability of women, the right to participate and make decisions in family matters, and finally their relative control over the sources of power.
Keywords: women's lifestyle, women of Lorestan, Small Lorestan region, tourists, military and political advisors.
 
 
Introduction: Different social layers such as class, gender, etc. are not separate one from another, but intertwined, and "lifestyle" is reflection of these layers. In the meantime, knowing "women's way of life" is of importance, in such a way that there has always been a reciprocal relationship between a woman's way of life and her family and social class in every historical period. Studies about Iranian ethnic women are less focused on women from specific ethnicities and often concentrate on the women of the aristocratic and courtier classes. The result of the research documented cases such as the complete subordination of women to men, the weak role of women in the family and social decision-making, the absence of benefits from power sources, the presence of women in internal affairs, restrictions caused by hijab, and prevalence of polygamy. In other words, regardless of cultural and ethnic diversity, feminist views such as the priority of men in societies and the inappropriate treatment of women have been expressed. It was neglected women come from diverse ethnicities, religions, and cultural backgrounds. Different societies represent gender and sexuality in various and contrasting ways that play a vital role in illustrating Women's position in society. Tourists and consultants often focus on Lorestan and have documented reports about women's lifestyles in this region. They have also compared the cultural contrasts between themselves and the observed society.
Methodology: Considering that the general perception of women's position in the traditional lifestyle of Iranian people refers to their subordinate and inferior role, lifestyle-based studies in social science and historical ethnography research provide an opportunity to reanalyze such presuppositions raised from early literature of the modern period. The current study applied the historical ethnographic approach and based on documentary sources analysis data in a descriptive-analytical way. Furthermore, according to the travelogues of travelers, military and political advisors presents the way of life of Lorestan women in the Qajar period and discover their position in the family and society.
Findings: The results reveal the reciprocal relationship between the way of life of men and women in this area in both society and family, as it releases doubt on the common beliefs about the superior position of men and the inferiority of women in this region. The women of Lorestan have had a relatively prominent position in the economic system, which led to their relative dominance over power sources, such as dominating living spaces, having financial independence, the right to participate and make decisions in family and social affairs. Regarding social system factors, women have had a similar position to the economic system, and of course, more prominent than the political system, and have had visible and hidden roles. The hidden and implicit roles of women have been reflected in the apparent authority of men. The authority of every man required having a potent wife or mother, so that the promotion of the social and family status of men, as well as their social competence and acceptance, had a direct association with the characteristics of the mother, wife, their social and family status, and vice versa. This has prevented the expansion and prevalence of the superiority of one and the inferiority of the other. It has generated a relative balance in all levels of family and social life, which can be a proof of not being low position of women in the family and society; However, in several cases, there has been a difference of opinion among men towards gender and women.
Discussion and conclusion: The attitude of tourists and military and political advisors whose reports and works were used in this research toward the situation of women in this region in many cases has been impartial, although in some circumstances they have compared it with the women of their countries. Women economically have been presented with relatively financial independence and a significant role in the economy of the family and society. From a social point of view, they have been mentioned as women with characteristics such as being social, interacting with acquaintances, relatives, and strangers, being less shy, hardworking, and participating in family and social decisions.

Keywords


Abbasi, Mahnaz, (2018), "Imagination of women in the travelogue Maghdasei", Cultural History Studies, 10th year, number 39, pp. 75-105. [In Persian]
Adler, A. (1997)." Understanding Life ", Oneworld Publications.
Afshar, Hasnali Khan, (2003),"The travelogue of Lorestan and Khuzestan Arak, Borujerd, Khorramabad, Dezful and Shushtar", Proofreading and research by Hamidreza Dalvand, Tehran, Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies. [In Persian]
Alfat, Saeeda, Salemi, Azadeh, (2012), "The concept of lifestyle", Lifestyle Studies, first year, number 1, pp. 36-9. [In Persian]
Alizadeh Birjandi, Zahra, Naseri, Akram, (2015), " A Survey on the Economical Participation of Urban Women in Qajar Period Based on the Foreign Tourist's Records", History of Iran after Islam, year 6, number 11, pp. 127-152. [In Persian]
Amirahmadi, Ahmad, (1994), "Memories of the First Lieutenant General of Iran", edited by Gholamreza Zargarinejad, Tehran, Research and Cultural Studies Institute, Vo l. [In Persian]
Ariyamanesh, Shahin, & Miri, Seyyed Java, (2016)," Critical look from the perspective of Historical Sociology to the issue of Orientalism A Critical Assessment of R. C. Zainer's Legacy", Journal of cultural society research, Volume 7, Number 4 - Serial Number 22, PP. 117-134. [In Persian]
Babaei, Mahbube, (2019),"Changing the social and economic role of women in contemporary Lorestan province", applied studies in social sciences and sociology, second year, number 1, pp. 95-101. [In Persian]
Bahar, Malek al-Shoaraye Bahar, Mohammad Taghi, (2008),"Brief history of political parties, extinction of Qajar", the first volume, Tehran, Zovar Publishing. [In Persian]
Bayat, sedigheh, Delbari; Shahrabano, Azim Zadeh Tehrani; Taherh, Motevali Haghighei, Youssof, (2018),"Comparison of women social situation in three travelogues written during Naser-al-Din Shah monarchy (1848-1896)", History Research Journal, 14th year, number 53, pp. 28-1. [In Persian]
Bell, David & Hollows, Joanne. (2006). "Historicizing lifestyle", Ashgate: London.
Bishop, Isabella Lucy Bird, (1996), "Jurneys in persia and Kurdistan", Translation: Mehrab Amiri, first edition, Tehran, Sahand Publishing. [In Persian]
Bourdieu, P. (1984), Distinction, New York: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Calhoun, Caring. Light, Donald, Keller, Suzanne, 1994, Sociology, New York, McGraw-Hill.
Curzon, George Nathaniel Curzon", (1994),‫ ‎Persia and the Persian question", Volume 2, translation: Gholam Ali Vahid Mazandarani, 4th edition, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Publications. [In Persian]
Digard, Jean Pierre, (2004), "Clothes in Iran land; from the series of articles in Iranica Encyclopedia: Clothing of the Bakhtiaris and other ethnic groups of the language", translated by: Peyman Matin, Volume 1, Tehran, Amirkabir Publishing. [In Persian]
Edmonds, Cecil John, (1845), "Lur, Luristan, Notes on Luristan and travles in Luristan and Arabistan", Translation: Sekander Amanullahei Baharvand, Laili Bakhtiar, Tehran, Babak Publishing. [In Persian]
Fasihizadeh, Azam, (2014), "Iranian woman from the point of view of foreign travel writers of the Qajar period", History Research, No. 64, pp. 155-172. [In Persian]
Feuvrier, Joannes, (2006), "Three years in the court of Iran", Translated: Abbas Eqbal Ashtiani, Tehran, Elm publication. [In Persian]
Ghasemi, Fareid, (1996), "History of Khorramabad", Khorramabad, Aflak Publishing. [In Persian]
Ghasemi, Fareid, (2017), "Khorramabad Documents: Petitions, Elections, Various", first edition, Tehran, published: Islamic Parliament Documents Center. [In Persian]
Grothe، Hugo, (1990), "travelogue", Translated by Majid Jalil Vand, Tehran: Publishing Center. [In Persian]
Hasani; Mohammad Hossein, Zakai; Mohammad Saeed, Talebi; Abu Torab, Entezari; Ali, (2016), "Conceptualization of cultural lifestyle", Cultural Research Society, Research Institute of Human Sciences and Cultural Studies Eighth year, number one,, pp. 23-45. [In Persian]
Hejazi, Banafsheh, (2021), "The history of ladies women status in Qajar dynasty", 4th edition, Tehran, Qaseidasera publishing. [In Persian]
Hurley, Frank, "Iran in the First World War", National Library of Australia Archives: https://www.nla.gov.au/using-library/getting-started/ask-librarian.
Kareimi, Bahman, (1950), "Roads and Old Capitals of Western Iran", Tehran, National Bank Printing House. [In Persian]
Kateb, Fatemeh, (2017), "Imagology" of Esfahan's Naqsh-e Jahan Square from the Perspective of Safavid Travel literatures", Theoretical foundations of visual arts, No. 4, pp. 111-121. [In Persian]
Ketabei, Ahmad, (2007), "Works of Najm al-Dowlen Najm al-Dowleh's second travel book to Khuzestan", Tehran, Research Institute of Human Sciences and Cultural Studies. [In Persian]
Layard, Austen Henry, (1988), "Early adventures in Persia susiana and Babylonia", Translated by Mehrab Amiri, Tehran, Vahid Publishing. [In Persian]
Mahdavi Keni, Mohammad Saeed, (2007), "The concept of style of life and its field in social sciences", Iranian cultural research, first year, Vo1, pp. 199-230. [In Persian]
Marcus, Clare Cooper, (2003), "House as Symbol of Self", Translation: Ahad Aliqlian, Art Academy Quarterly, No. 5, pp. 84-119. [In Persian]
Mckee, J. B. (1969), Introduction to Sociology, Holt Rinehart and Winston Inc.
Mehrabadi, Mitra, (2000), "Iranian woman's according to the travelogue of foreign writers", first edition, Tehran, Roozerg and Afarinesh publishing house. [In Persian]
Panahei; Abbas, Mohammadzadeh, Asadullah, (2016), "The image of Iranian woman in the travelogues of the French since the beginning of the period Qajar until the constitutional revolution Based on Stuart Hall's theory of representation", Journal of the Iranian History Association, 7th year, 27th issue, pp. 1-23. [In Persian]
Rahmati, Mohsen, & Dalvand, Mohammad. (2016). "The role of readers and influential people in establishing security in Lorestan during the first Pahlavi era", Social History Research, 7th year, 1st issue, pp. 137-153, Tehran, Research Institute of Human Sciences and Cultural Studies. [In Persian]
Rapoport, Amos, (2018), "Housing Anthropology", translation: Khosro Afzalian, 4th edition, Tehran, Kasari Library Publishing. [In Persian]
Rawlinson, Henry Creswicke, (1983),"Notes on a March From Zahab to the foot of Zagros, alongThe Mountain of khuzistan, (Susiana) and from Thence ThroughThe Province of Luristan To Kermanshah in The Year 1836", Translation: Sekander Amanulahi Baharvand, first edition, Tehran, Agah publishing. [In Persian]
Rice, Clara colliver, (2004), "Persian women", Translation: Asadollah Azad, first edition, Tehran, Ketabdar Publishing. [In Persian]
Sayah Mahalati, Mirza Mohammad Ali, (1967), "Memoires of Haj Sayah", edited by Seyfullah Golkar, first edition, Tehran, Amirkabir publishing. [In Persian]
Sevruguin, Antoin, (1999), "Iran from a perspective Sevruguin ", translated: Sahar Barjasteh, first edition, Tehran, Zaman Publishing. [In Persian]
Shahsavari, Soraya, Najjar, Saeid, (2014), "Investigating the impact of the modernization policies of Reza Shah on Brialt and the tribes of Lorestan", two quarterly journals of Iranian Local History Journal, second year, third issue, pp. 52-66. [In Persian]
Shushtri, Mir Abdul Latif Khan, (1984), "Tohfah Al-Alam and Zeil Al Tohfah, Travelogue and Diaries", Mowahed, Samad, Tehran, Tahori Publishing. [In Persian]
Simmel, G. (1990), the Philosophy of Money, Tom Boomer and David Frisby (Trans), Second Enlarged Ed, New York: Routledge.
Stark, Freya, (1985), "The Valleys of the Assassins and other Persian Travels: A trip to Diyar Alamut, Lorestan and Ilam ", Translation: Ali Mohammad Saki, second edition, Tehran, Scientific Publications. [In Persian]
Valizadeh Moejezi, Mohammad Reza, (2001), "History of Lorestan during the Pahlavi Era", first edition, Tehran, Horufeiyeh publishing house. [In Persian]
Valizadeh Moejezi, Mohammad Reza, (2003), the history of Lorestan during the Qajar era from establishment until the 1920", first edition, Tehran, Horufeiyeh publishing house. [In Persian]
Veal A. J (2000). "Leisure, Culture and Lifestyle ", Volume 24, Number 2, autumn 2001, Culture et mode de vie.
Wilson, Arnold Talbot, (1968), " Political and economic history of southwestern Iran", Translation: Hossein Saadat, Tehran, Vahid Publishing. [In Persian]
Yousefvand, Saman, Entezari, Ali, Moradi Nezhad, Zeinab, (2018), Women's semantic understanding of modernization in local society, case study: Lorestan province", Social and Cultural Strategy, 7th year, 28th issue, pp. 285-317. [In Persian]
Zal al-Sultan, Masoud, (1989), "Memories of Zal al-Sultan: Masoudi's biography", Hossein Khadio Jam, volume 2, first edition, Tehran, Asatir Publishing. [In Persian]